Subculture Anime Blog

ef – a tale of melodies. – 12 (Final)

screenshotscreenshotscreenshot

Ghost of xmas pa-…. My final impression is included.

screenshotscreenshotscreenshotscreenshotscreenshotscreenshotscreenshotscreenshotscreenshotscreenshotscreenshotscreenshotscreenshotscreenshotscreenshotscreenshotscreenshotscreenshotscreenshotscreenshotscreenshotscreenshotscreenshotscreenshotscreenshotscreenshotscreenshot

Summary:

Yuu visits Yuuko’s grave, relaying what has been happening recently and leaving with the fact that he will not be able to stop by for awhile. As it is xmas day, all of the familiar couples spend their time together. This includes Mizuki and Kuze, who have been doing well with each other for quite awhile. When Nagi visits Yuu, having been in Japan until recently, she sees that he is drawing quite well as usual. After some idle talk, she takes the chance to question if he is still thinking about Yuuko. Yuu only answers with his usual belief that he has forgotten, however. When all of the friends in Australia gather, they sit to listen to Kuze’s violin and Mizuki’s song in the church.

When Yuu meets Kuze later, he listens as he recalls his belief that he wouldn’t last until another xmas. It had been one year since his operation. As Kuze has gotten a lot better since then, Yuu believes his job has finally ended. With this, he tells Kuze that he has something to make sure of in Japan. Kuze gives Yuu a charm in the form of the rooftop keys before he leaves, wishing him luck. Previously, Nagi had mentioned the strange things her brother had told her. This was that he had met Amamiya Yuuko.

Visiting the old church, Yuu finally meets Yuuko. He has come in search for someone, and she has always been waiting for someone. Yuu finally has the chance to give Yuuko flowers as a xmas gift, and although Yuuko does not believe she has anything in return, Yuu shows that he certainly has the scarf that she made him several years ago. The two sit down together to discuss how much has changed throughout the years, especially with Miki and their other acquaintances, and Yuu credits their ability to meet to the experiences that the other couples had gone through. Yuuko then mentions that she was once told that her duty was to continue to be happy, suggesting that it might have been a message from god. When Yuuko asks if Yuu still believes that god does not exist, he only expresses that he simply lives in his own way. Showing her the keys he has, Yuu eventually asks if Yuuko would come with her to the place where everything started.

Alone together on the rooftop, Yuu finally takes the chance to express his love for Yuuko. Unfortunately, Yuuko corrects him by saying that he loved her. Of course, this meant that Yuuko would finally have to leave. Trying to hold back his tears, Yuu confirms that he will be okay. After all, he has already come so far while being alone. As the clouds open up for her, Yuuko leaves with the wish that Yuu would continue to help people be happy. Finding that she is now gone, Yuu is no longer able to hide his sadness.

Observing the city with her later, Yuu finally tells Mizuki that his dream was to create a beautiful city. This brings the two to recall their belief that nothing will start without a dream. Mizuki goes on to tell Yuu that his dream is not a lie, as everyone’s feelings of happiness are in its creation. Mizuki finds that she has accidentally grasped onto Yuu’s hand after observing the city with him, but this only leads Yuu to wonder if she no longer sees frightening dreams anymore. Yuu mentions that he never properly learned Mizuk’s namei, so she confirms that she was once named “Miki.”

screenshotscreenshotscreenshot

Insert: A full color OP, with happy endings replacing the usual characters bursting into feathers. In the end, Yuuko is revealed to be something of an angel.

screenshotscreenshotscreenshot

ED: A happy ending in the true shaft/ef fashion. Everyone is shown living their everyday lives in a sketchy type style.

Impression:

Yuuko, you are a traitor to all atheists around the world! It’s okay though, we still love you.

So, who saw the time skip coming? After watching all the couples during xmas, I don’t think it was a surprise to anyone that Mizuki would be with Kuze. (That would be such a weird relationship though. Kuze is now like Ken Akamatsu with his cosplay wife.) I really loved the bgm tracks in this episode, and Kuze’s playing with now-singer(?) Mizuki was pretty epic. It was so perfect how everything came together with Yuu and Yuuko too, coming off as very bittersweet despite the fact that we all saw what was coming. Mizuki’s holding hands with Yuu like they did in the past was a really nice touch too, though this also ended up being really awkward because of how everything turned out in the end. Kuze, it is always pedophilia until they grow up.

Notes:

  • Nice party hat, Chihiro.
  • Danke, lol.
  • A few days early for xmas, no?
  • Big pink scarfs, a true sign of love.
  • Yuuko has been watching a lot of Persona or something.
  • lol@Miyako trying to draw.

Final Impression:

I usually start feeling jaded after going through so many seasons of nothing but bad to mediocre anime, filled with only mindless comedy or action, but it’s shows like this that remind me why I continue to watch anime. The ending of this episode alone made me empathize with the feeling of simply wanting to continue living, as well as making me recall how much I love storytelling. I don’t think it’s a secret to anyone anymore that SHAFT is my favorite studio, and they continue to be with their constant pushing of boundaries both visually and creatively. Probably not as impacting as the first season, simply because I had already known what to expect, but ef – a tale of melodies. remained extremely beautiful none of the less. The backgrounds that the creators have as artists is so evident when I watch this production, from being absorbed in the moods created by choice of color to the non-traditional forms of visual storytelling. Sure, the shock factor that the first season had might have been missing this time around, but the symbolism through speech or otherwise was as strong as ever.

Melodies. filled in all the gaps that were evident in the first season, most obviously with Yuu and Yuuko’s backgrounds. I would appreciate it for that reason alone, but the stories that were presented were quite strong in their own right as well. The only reason this season did not seem as strong as the first was probably because I had already become quite used to what to expect from the series. (Would I have found Yuuko’s abuse and Kuze’s depression more impacting if I hadn’t already gone through similar paths with Miyako and Chihiro?) The story itself was also on a more subtle, and generally bittersweet, path. Whereas the first season seemed to focus more on the power of love, I felt like this one taught the importance of living. Of course, both series still shared very similar themes on different levels. Although many were expecting a second season after memories ended (myself included), it finally looks like this is the end of ef. It has been an extremely enjoyable experience, and I now only look forward to seeing more and more quality productions from studio SHAFT in the upcoming seasons.

17 comments

17 Comments so far

  1. Haruka December 22nd, 2008 11:06 pm

    The end was wonderful. I loved both seasons and am sad to see it wrap to an end, but it’s just perfect during this holiday season. ef will always be memorable in my eyes and a masterpiece from SHAFT. Kudos to minori all the way too. I can’t wait for the OST on December 26th. Thanks for the review as well.

  2. JohnnyQuest December 23rd, 2008 3:36 am

    That old guy gets to spread that young blonde, all day and all night…

  3. shh227 December 23rd, 2008 6:24 am

    As we all knew it was going to be a happy ending, which is good. Nice xmas theme to the show too considering it will be xmas very soon.

    LOL! Kuze is now like Ken Akamatsu!

  4. kencute321 December 23rd, 2008 10:02 am

    the ending is just as i predicted. I was expecting for a twist though. Well, hnestly its yuu&yuuko’s story dat made this season interesting. Compared to ef memories,molodies is less interesting(hnestly it sucks!). But still the story is good! Hooray next season animes!

  5. Diss December 23rd, 2008 11:51 am

    Is Ken Akamtsu’s waifu really young? I’d say the Kuze/Mizuki age gap is like 10 years, which is not too terribly weird. For anime.

  6. Myssa Rei December 23rd, 2008 5:05 pm

    Well, it was pretty much a happy ending for everyone except Yuuko and Yuu, but that was kind of expected when it was revealed (though many suspected it for some time) that Yuuko was dead. It is a bit bittersweet in their case, though you have to wonder what some of the younger cast think when they find out that they’ve been advised by what amounts to a ghost…

    You really have to hand it to SHAFT with their direction of ef. Had it been a different studio, and had the show been directed in the standard eroge adaptation manner, it probably wouldn’t have done as well.

  7. Totali December 23rd, 2008 5:14 pm

    Yea, I discussed that in my review of the first season. Without the visual direction and all the extra attention to detail, I would have not even cared for this show, let alone have it be one of my favorites. Shaft, f yea \o/

  8. Myssa Rei December 23rd, 2008 7:35 pm

    One final note though. Yuuko once mentioned that Yuu blinked whenever he was lying. Fast forward to the last half of this episode…

  9. Rawr December 23rd, 2008 10:35 pm

    Himura has it pretty tough. Shitty childhood, shitty teenage years, and shitty adulthood? Wow, does that all add up to shitty life? I think god, or in this case the writers, hates him.

  10. Taiki Langley December 24th, 2008 4:53 pm

    This is the latest chapter?

  11. DarkShadower December 26th, 2008 10:31 pm

    So, Yuuko is now a goddess of love? Its really a bitter-sweet ending.

  12. Haruka December 27th, 2008 8:44 am

    About the blinking when he lies. The end was really sad considering when he said he loved her, he didn’t blink at all, but when it came down to him saying he will be fine without her was when the guy basically lied full-out. That’s kinda depressing, but well. At the beginning of the episode was when I really felt the start of the emotional rollercoaster. The BGM, the colors, and the artistic approach was outstandingly elegant and simple.

  13. san December 29th, 2008 5:28 pm

    Damn it, I expected Yuu kun to get together with Nagi chan and live happily ever after, dammit, dammit, dammit! ;-)

    Other than that, nice anime. The ending is a bit more painful than the first season but yeah, it’s finally all wrapped up. Expect Kuze to die in a year or two though. :-P

  14. Dando008 December 31st, 2008 9:15 am

    @san: You got that right…I mean Nagi has had a crush on Yuu for the longest and is still ready and willing to get with him…I would still think that they would eventually get together.

  15. san January 1st, 2009 4:07 am

    @Dando008: Even I hope so, but given that he promised Yukko he would *always* love her and continue to look over the town to make sure no one suffers, I doubt that. :-(

    @Haruka: It really was pretty sad that he couldn’t help but lie to Yukko that he would be OK without her. In normal animes, the person would just move on and try to be happy with some woman but he choose to keep loving her. :-(

    -san

  16. ruby January 6th, 2009 2:28 am

    hi, anyone out there who knows the title of yukko’s song? The one mizuki sang with lyrics too I think on the last episode..I’ve been wondering what it’s called in japanese. The title for the violin version is ‘a moon filled sky’ right?

  17. Squanto January 13th, 2009 6:24 am

    halfway into this season, I realized it was the second instead of the first. I decided to finish anyway. I don’t think I’ll be watching the first season after seeing this. A looooot of emotion was pushed out of me. It was a nice ride and I am glad I watched it. All thanks to you. :D

    Can’t agree more when you say that shows like this keep you watching anime. ^^d

Leave a reply